Our research

ongoing projects

Governance of state-owned enterprises: economic performance, social utility, political influence

Hydro-Québec, Santé Québec, Loto-Québec, SAQ, STM, state-owned enterprises, play a central role in Quebec’s economic and social development. They manage major collective assets, employ thousands of people, and fulfill public interest missions in key sectors. Their governance, at the intersection of politics and economics, poses unique challenges.

How can the strategic autonomy of state-owned corporations be preserved while respecting government policy? What are the effects of politicization on decision-making, the appointment of directors, and the capacity for innovation? And above all, what specific role does the CEO play in regulating these tensions between political demands and management imperatives?

In order to analyze these issues in depth, Pôle D has launched a research program entitled Governing Crown Corporations: Economic Performance, Social Utility, Political Influence. This research aims to better understand the institutional mechanisms, rationales for action, and leadership skills that shape the governance of these organizations. It also aims to fuel public debate by proposing concrete avenues for improvement.

The project is led by Prof. Alaric Bourgoin and Prof. Denis Chênevert (HEC Montréal), in collaboration with Luc Tremblay (former CEO of the STM), Alain Brunet (former CEO of the SAQ), and Nancy Chahwan (former federal deputy minister). The methodology combines a quantitative survey of a large sample of CEOs and directors of state-owned enterprises with some 40 qualitative interviews conducted with executives, board members, and senior civil servants. The analysis is structured around three areas:

  1. Institutional governance mechanisms (appointment procedures, role and functioning of boards of directors, formal and informal accountability mechanisms);
  2. The dynamics of politicization (influence of electoral cycles and government priorities on strategic decisions);
  3. Political leadership skills (managing tensions between economic performance, public expectations, and political pressures).

With this project, Pôle D has two objectives. The first is to generate new knowledge in a field that, despite its strategic importance, has received little attention in academic literature. The second is to formulate concrete recommendations for CEOs, board members, and public decision-makers to better equip them to deal with such a complex environment. The results will make it possible to identify the conditions that promote greater strategic autonomy, clarify the division of responsibilities between political actors and executives, and contribute to more effective, transparent, and legitimate governance of state-owned enterprises.

Among peers: when CEOs learn from each other

Between the corridors of power and the laboratory of ideas, peer groups of leaders—confidential circles where CEOs and entrepreneurs exchange ideas—are attracting growing interest. Far removed from hierarchical structures, these spaces offer leaders a privileged setting in which to share their challenges, discuss their strategic dilemmas, and learn from their experiences. They are rare opportunities for listening, reflection, and solidarity—essential resources for leaders who are often isolated by their position.

Research has shown that external networks of leaders influence organizational performance. In some cases, peer support is even more influential than support from personal circles. However, their role in decision-making dynamics, resilience, and leadership practices remains largely unexplored.

It is in this context that Pôle D, in partnership with EntreChefs PME, is conducting an in-depth study of these peer groups and their effects. Beyond its scientific scope, this study aims to produce knowledge that is directly useful to practitioners: designing more effective support mechanisms, equipping mentors and facilitators, and supporting leaders in their professional and personal development.

This project is based on a dual quantitative and qualitative approach. The quantitative component, led by Prof. Jean-François Harvey, is based on a survey of 500 entrepreneurs who are members of peer groups. The qualitative component, led by Prof. Alaric Bourgoin and researcher Tristan Dupas Amory (a graduate of ESCP Business School), is based on some 50 in-depth interviews with CEOs from various sectors and involved in different circles.

Several actors are involved: the organizations that structure and run these groups, the mentors who facilitate them on a daily basis, and the leaders who find in them a confidential space for dialogue, reflection, and progress.

By placing the voices of leaders at the heart of the analysis, Pôle D is continuing its mission: to better understand the realities of the CEO profession, in all their complexity, in order to inform action and fuel practical reflection.

Breaking the loneliness at the top: understanding and taking action

According to a study by the Harvard Business Review, 50% of executives experience loneliness, and among them, 61% believe that it negatively impacts their performance. The perception that “it’s lonely at the top” has become commonplace, yet empirical studies exploring this reality among executives remain rare. One might assume that CEOs, often equipped with extensive networks and remarkable social skills, are not prone to feelings of loneliness. However, it manifests itself in ways that defy the usual stereotypes.

The image we have of loneliness is a little person all alone… and there’s a potted plant, and the little person alone in the room. But that’s not the loneliness of a CEO. Loneliness is in your head, all the time, even if you’re surrounded by 50 people.

– Executive and founder, 2,500 employees.

Our research program explores the antecedents, dynamics, and impacts of loneliness on leaders, their teams, and their organizations. This research project takes a multi-method approach that integrates quantitative and qualitative studies conducted with Canadian senior leaders. We are also developing a specific measurement scale to better understand loneliness among leaders. This study is being conducted by an international team as part of the activities of Pôle D, composed of Prof. Alaric Bourgoin, Prof. Denis Chênevert, Prof. Jean-François Harvey, and Daniel Wolfgruber, all four affiliated with HEC Montréal, Prof. Peter Harms (University of Alabama), Prof. Sarah Wright (University of Canterbury), and Prof. Saouré Kouamé (Telfer School, University of Ottawa).

 

The project aims to deepen our understanding of loneliness among leaders, focusing on what characterizes the experience of loneliness in situations of power and under intense performance pressure. The goal is to provide leaders with concrete strategies to alleviate feelings of loneliness, while promoting the development of healthy relationships and a positive work environment within their teams and organizations.

Strategizing in times of crisis

The current COVID-19 pandemic is an unprecedented crisis facing modern organizations, but it is also a rare opportunity for researchers to open the boardrooms of certain Canadian companies, which have been largely invisible in the literature on strategy and board governance until now.

We propose to take a close look at what CEOs and boards of directors do, how they work together to generate and analyze strategic alternatives, i.e., their strategic activities and practices, in board meetings during and after the COVID-19 pandemic.
Video ethnography is the primary research methodology for this program. It allows for repeated examination of important episodes during data analysis. It provides a means of close documentation and observation and offers unprecedented opportunities for analysis, collaboration, and archiving.
To our knowledge, this study is the first longitudinal comparative video-ethnographic study of interactions between CEOs and boards of directors. The research program we propose is important given that there is little research on Canadian CEOs and boards of directors in general, and on how they work together to make strategic decisions during and after the COVID-19 pandemic in particular. The lessons learned from this study will help leaders of other organizations improve the effectiveness of strategic decision-making during potential future crises. The findings from this study will extend existing theories on CEO-board interactions in strategic decision-making, board roles and responsibilities, and board composition.

Leading a management team: balance, tensions, and leverage

While they may sometimes feel alone at the top, no CEO is an island: the organization’s top executive works closely with their team, which plays a key role in strategic decision-making, particularly during statutory meetings with the executive committee or the board of directors. Our research breaks new ground by incorporating video ethnography—the filmed study of participants’ verbal and nonverbal communication interactions in meetings—to better understand the decision-making dynamics at the top of organizations.

One organization opened its doors to allow us to record all of its statutory meetings. This type of primary data, which is extremely rare in scientific research, greatly enriches our analysis. We explore both the interactions between participants—a close-up look at the lived experience of leaders—and broader perspectives on the key moments and critical incidents that punctuate strategic decision-making over time. This dual level of observation provides us with a deep understanding, both practical and theoretical, of how management teams collectively design, implement, and adjust their strategies. The project is also distinguished by its comparative dimension, enriching our team’s previous research with this new data corpus, thereby facilitating the identification of best practices.

This SSHRC-funded study is jointly led by Professor Feng Liu of Saint Mary’s University, Professor Alaric Bourgoin and Professor Linda Rouleau, as well as postdoctoral researcher Daniel Wolfgruber, all three of whom are members of HEC Montréal. Video ethnography, the main method used in our project, allows us to capture participants’ verbal and nonverbal communication in detail, while tracking the evolution of strategic decisions throughout the meetings.We believe this study is the first longitudinal and comparative video-ethnographic analysis of interactions between CEOs and their management teams. This pioneering research offers unique insights into the emotional dynamics and influence strategies within management teams, with the hope of helping leaders optimize strategic decision-making during statutory meetings.

Designing the organization of the future: the role of the CEO

Many organizations are seeking to revise the traditional organizational model in favor of so-called “liberated” or “holacratic” structures that are less focused on hierarchy. These new configurations promote self-determination and empowerment among employees, who collaborate freely on organizational decisions. While much practice oriented as well as academic studies have focused on analyzing the structural and technological changes driving these transformations, the role of the CEO remains less studied.

One person should not give orders to another person, but both should agree to take orders from the situation.

– Mary Parker Follet, The Dynamic Organization.

How are roles and accountabilities shared in these so-called “liberated” organizations, and how is power distributed? How do decision-making mechanisms work, particularly when managing complex tasks or in crisis situations? How is the role of the CEO evolving within these organizations, which are often seen as models for the future in societies that promote equality, inclusion, and the active participation of all employees? This research project aims to explore these questions and provide some answers.

Pôle D is conducting an extensive three-year ethnographic case study focused on the cultural and organizational transformation of a major Quebec transportation company adopting a less hierarchical model. This research includes monthly interviews with the CEO to gain an in-depth understanding of his challenges and vision, in parallel with the organizational transformation. This project is the doctoral thesis doctorate of Simon Altmejd and is supervised by professors Alaric Bourgoin (HEC Montréal), Samer Faraj (McGill University), Linda Rouleau (HEC Montréal), and Saku Mantere (McGill University).

This project aims to provide detailed analyses, rooted in the reality of the field, on the evolution of leadership when organizational models that presented as less hierarchical are introduced. Ethnographic observation of the role of CEOs is a major challenge, mainly due to difficulties in accessing the field. Through this work, the Pôle D teams are striving to build bridges between the academic world and leaders. The results of this research will provide expertise and tools to leaders in their efforts to rethink their management practices and support organizational and cultural transformations.

Diversity at the top: the career paths of minority CEOs

Numerous studies have shown that racial disparities create barriers that hinder the careers of minority executives, particularly in companies where they are underrepresented. A 2021 study by the Harvard Business Review reveals that many Black executives feel marginalized and unsupported, forcing them to work twice as hard to prove their worth despite their skills. In Canada, research also shows that minority workers are underrepresented in leadership positions due to numerous challenges, including limited access to networks and infrastructure, particularly those related to funding (HRPA, 2024). Those who do reach high positions still face a variety of socio-psychological pressures that continually test their leadership style and managerial approaches.

This research aims to better understand the experiences of Black CEOs who face some form of stigma in their work environment. We seek to understand the obstacles they encounter, as well as the strategies they use to overcome these obstacles and succeed in their professional roles.

As part of her doctoral thesis, Becky Larry-Izamoje, a researcher on the research team, is using social status theory to explore the impact of these dynamics on minority CEOs and how they manage to thrive professionally despite certain tensions.

Pôle D is conducting a multi-method study based on more than 50 interviews with CEOs from minority groups in Canada. Using this qualitative data, we are developing a model of legitimization strategies used by diverse CEOs, which will then be tested using a quantitative approach. This research project is also led by Prof. Russell Fralich (HEC Montréal), a specialist in issues related to the impact of social judgments on the strategic choices of leaders.

The objective of this research is to offer a perspective that draws on work on social status and stigma to better understand the challenges of diversity in professional environments. We also aim to take a positive and pragmatic look at strategies that enable minority CEOs to succeed despite a set of constraints. These strategies can then be used by practitioners to promote the inclusion of minority leaders in Canadian organizations.

Sources

Cooper et Gelati (2021), Harvard Business Review, “Marginalized Groups: What Do Black Executives Really Want?” Retrieved from : HBR.

HRPA (2024), Human Resources Professionals Association, “Creating Psychological Safety for Black Leaders: Conversation with Chivon John.” Retrieved from : HRPA.